Talk:Evelynn/Background/@comment-41.212.12.214-20120619083058/@comment-68.98.9.242-20120622212554

Can't tell if trolling or not.

36% damage return as a passive is completely broken and would allow her to duel practically anyone in the game. Not to mention it's penalizing players in teamfights for focusing a carry, which is what is supposed to happen, it's how the game works. The AP carry shouldn't lose over a third of their health because they bursted the correct target, and the AD carry could never duel her, she'd win every time versus every carry. She could just build warmogs and have everyone die attacking her, thornmail and over 50% damage return auto attacking her.

While I agree her passive should lower nuetral camp damage, 50% is too much, and 25% heal off of minions/monsters is absurd sustain, thats over 100 hp regen for every last hit on a melee minion and 70hp on caster minions at level 1. She would get over 500hp in sustain every single wave, increasing by 33 every 3 minutes not including seige minions which would give 175+ hp for last hitting. She would be impossible to push out of lane and could just win every trade just because last hitting would sustain her back to full.

A small buff to her q and e sure, but realize that her Q is a half second cooldown with max cdr and your asking for it to be given 80% AD, again that would be absurd. 1.5 AD ratio would also be far too high for E.

W change would be a joke, again, impossible to kill duelist.

I don't know how strong her old ultimate was, so I won't comment on that.

And I'll just hope your trolling because those changes would be so absurdly ridiculous.