Board Thread:League of Legends discussion/@comment-5489694-20140310172442/@comment-5209745-20140927195405

The thing is, unlike Karma and Trundle reworks, both Poppy and Sion are not fine in the game, at least not in Summoner's rift. Sure, Poppy is fine in Twisted treeline, but the balance engine is usually directed towards SR.

As I said before, Poppy simply doesn't works in SR because of situational stun, farming ineptitude, and huge mana-managemente problems; the latter also goes for Sion, whom while might have a better chance to work with his ranged stun, is so easily kitable and slow, that even if well-farmed, he won't have any impact in the game- so imagine how bad it goes for our yordlelette.

So yeah, she's weak. Problem is, if should she get ahead, she would become retardedly OP with her outstanding tankyness and huge base/bonus AD and base damages. That kind of binarism has never been healthy for the game, nor for the character itself.

Admit it, she has all the tickets for a rework.