User blog comment:C9 Teemur/Paige, the Phoenix Guardian/@comment-25235491-20170216212745

Here's my criticism on the patch notes.


 * General:
 * I doubt the stats needed any increase. 56 is not usual base AD for a, more like a 's. I even was saying the armor was a bit high for my tastes.
 * P - Phoenixfire Ash
 * I'm pretty sure Ash recovery shouldn't have a cooldown - if she shouldn't generate Ash while the phoenix is active, you don't need more restrictions than this.
 * Q - Burning Breath
 * Still damage. You may as well remove the collision damage or such, but that's personal design ideas.
 * The should decay I'm sure, because 20% for 4 seconds is still quite strong. I don't think any slow lasts 4 seconds anymore.
 * W - Phoenix Egg
 * I'm pretty sure most abilities of this kind have base damage for a reason.
 * I'm not sure the root duration needed to be increased (even by a measly second).
 * E - Flame Flight
 * The design flaw that I explained stays, so yeah.
 * Add to that, your escape is a 550-range dash, with a 1-second windup time. Which is horribad.
 * R - Unleash the Phoenix
 * Don't make non-linear scalings for no reason (especially when a correct scaling would be ).
 * Why couldn't the Phoenix just have the same attack speed as Paige?
 * It just brings the point: all its stats scale on Paige's with some odd scalings to make it different, but most pets have their own stats (well, some stats).