Talk:Garen/@comment-24090792-20131108143606/@comment-5955640-20131109075935

The magic damage is completely flat and doesn't scale and it really just exists specfically to circumvent armor which people would always have more of than Magic resistance.

You only use it on people with 30 percent health or less. Flat ranking attack damage would be a nerf espescially against Garen's opponents in top lane. Scaling Attack damage would be a buff but a really huge one. A single target spell that either goes through or doesn't go off would be a huge nuke in lane.

If you aren't the tank Garen could nuke you for an incredible amount of damage and that's overlooking the fact that Garen can already deal a lot of damage with just the crits he's allowed to make with Q and E and armor pen. That an Garen tanks. It's like wanting Rammus's spells to actually scale off Attack damage. Oh yeah you'll do more damage. Too much!