Talk:Urgot/@comment-4167645-20140618033041/@comment-24558666-20140622215055

Could someone explain to me what in Urgot screams Essence Reaver?

- his Q does not interact with NIETHER life steal, nor mana life steal

- he needs mana way sooner before he can finish Essence reaver

- Tear of goddess already solves mana problem, and with muramana, becomes god tier item late game

- together with Muramana(which is, established by previous arguments superior item choice), Essence reaver does not provide much - again, it does not interact with q, and 50 AD + 10 cdr are equivalent to the black cleaver, which for 350 more gold provide armor shred, armor penetration and bonus health instead of useless stats like life steal and excessive mana sustain.

So, we arive at conclusion:

1) Tear > ER

2) Manamune + ER < Manamune + Cleaver

Usually Manamune and cleaver are good enough, sacrifiing another defensive item for third damage item seems suboptimal, as muramana provides enough ad with Frozen Heart. So, where am I wrong, please?