User blog comment:NeonSpotlight/Where did comments go?/@comment-1915726-20120808133710/@comment-2124153-20120808145051

I didn't say that the Talk page was inadequate, I said that it was hilariously inadequate. That is to say, so inadequate that it makes me laugh. It's on a different page. It doesn't automatically thread. The editor itself a morass of confusion that is impenetrable to people who aren't familiar with wikis.

The Talk page is a solution to a problem, but the problem is "how do I crater my userbase?", not "how do I replace comments?"