User blog comment:ClariS/Kayle's Primary Role/@comment-4442345-20120310195602/@comment-4881935-20120310211709

What I think about old Kayle vs new Kayle? Well, assuming when you say old Kayle as the one with the dual scaling passive, I can actually say that I love the new Kayle more because I think her entire kit works better as a whole. Old Kayle's spell set did not work will with all mighty passive for a few reasons: 1) She had no incentive to grab AD beyond her innate passive (as righteous fury sucked back then) 2) Grabbing AP gave you more gold worth of stats, even when compared to hybrid items like Gunblade 3) Her passive was the only reason why people would claim Kayle was an 'hybrid' champion, which is sad because I love playing champion as Hybrid.

Saying that, I think the new Kayle is a weaker then the old one, but I think Kayle can do well as an AD carry if she can get find a place during the lane phase (i like bot with a tank).