Talk:Maokai/@comment-4636093-20121225130529/@comment-78.2.149.212-20121225173152

I don't play top lane so I can't really tell which one is better, but I can tell you that you shouldn't be taking either top as they won't get significantly better with farm and you can't shut down the opposing top lane hard enough (if he or she isn't horrible) to justify taking them top.

Junglewise Maokai is overall better because while gankwise they are about equal (mostly because Maokai's W is stupidly easy to use) surviving with Nautilus in the jungle against any bruiser or assassin that decides to pay you a visit is almost an artform.