User blog comment:Zilla4444/AD upgrade for Chalice of Harmony/@comment-77.99.48.111-20120611230435

I want an AD Challace, but I don't really like either item.

The first seems a little lackluster in terms of a legendary tier item (merely high stats), and--while I'd love another Brutalizer path--I've seen so many posts about why it's not to be.

And the second's passive seems a little complicated and a too niche for an item whose audience is quite large. Kog'Maw, Corki (mostly), Tristana and Twitch are some examples of mana-hungry AD carries who don't benefit from armor pen on their abilities... actually, now I think of it, Ezreal, Miss Fortune, Graves, etc, only have one physical damage ability too (not including ultimates, although the point is still true for a lot of those champions even including ultimates).

You know what the best additional passive would be?

Passive UNIQUE: [Your attacks/Your attacks and single target abilities] replenishes [9/12/15/a percentage of the damage dealt as] mana.