Talk:Ashe/@comment-24299177-20150507092306/@comment-14081808-20150513154522

@Johnnyboy38

"R should deal magic damage equal to a normal or innate crit, with base damage added that scales with ulti level which is only applyed to frosted targets."

That's your version. Getting the most of your ult on a single person (during laning) would require you to apply her debuff, and the best way to do that is an AA.

And seeing how as you described it it would do either an innate (equal to AA) or normal (obviously stronger than an AA) crit PLUS extra base damage for being frosted, it replacing an AA would be acceptable.

Now if you want to talk numbers, then here:

Currently, the passive as I understand it scales your damage equal to your crit chance instead of giving you a chance to crit. This means that with just the base crit chance of IE before its passive at level 6, Ashe would have ~150 AD before runes and masteries. Add 25% and her AAs would deal 190 easily with her passive, again before IE does some extra work. So, unless you have some negligible base bonus of less than 50, her R would deal more damage than it does now with your wording. Period.

Don't insult my intelligence. It will always surprise you.