Talk:Singed/@comment-24.211.198.153-20130119160442/@comment-4068613-20130120170915

You conveniently ignored the mana->hp scaling on RoA, assumed you've been holding it for less than one minute, added the mana->hp scaling on Seraph's, and assumed that you've already fully stacked a tear.

An unstacked RoA gives you 562.5, 450 and 60, and a fully stacked RoA gives you 812.5, 650, and 80. And the Catalyst passive saves lives, don't forget.

Seraph's gives a marginal amount more mana and less than a third of the health. The AP is definitely superior when you factor in other mana items, but I would take 562 life over ~30-50 AP any day on Singed.