Talk:Garen/@comment-77.98.249.112-20121019015745/@comment-4878039-20121019112535

I would say it is inferior to Noxian Guillotine. While it scales with the enemy's missing HP, that's it. Riven has an AD scaling + a missing hp scaling and Darius can double his ult damage with Hemorrage stacks. Not to mention Darius's deals true damage, obviously meaning that if the enemy has as much HP as the ult will deal it's a certain kill. Should the ultimate leave the enemy with low HP, Hemorrage will most probably net the kill on them.

Garen's ult deals magic damage and if the enemy has a pretty basic 100 Magic res the damage is halved. Garen shouldn't be getting Magic Pen so he can't help it. Garen's ult is supposed to be better at killing tough targets because of the % missing HP Scaling but it isn't since Noxian Guillotine will always deal full damage but Demacian Justice gets its damage cut by MRes.

On top of that Guillotine's cooldown is lower than Justice's on lower ranks and Guillotine's cooldown is refreshed on kill. Oh and Guillotine has more range and I've actually experienced it to be a quicker cast than Demacian Justice.

I still do prefer Garen over Darius as a champion, but the ults need balancing.