Talk:Kayle/@comment-94.65.45.37-20120831062616/@comment-2124153-20120904225107

I know exactly what it takes to deal a certain amount of damage, but as I said, it requires that you "more or less continuously autoattack". This is not at all feasible. Even against a modestly armored target you're looking at 20-25% physical damage reduction, you can't lifesteal against towers, and meleeing while Righteous Fury is on cooldown requires that you get right in someone's face. You are never going to hit the theoretical maximum of ~3200 physical damage per minute with a level 5 Kayle using a Doran's Blade; however you WILL hit the ~65 health/minute healed with a Doran's Ring Kayle, because literally all that it needs is that you push W. There is no comparison, especially when you consider the potential downsides of pushing indiscriminately.

Hybrid and AD are not close. My comparison shows that it was, because I messed up the math and gave AD more than it was due. If you notice, 2x Doran's + Zeal has more AD than Rageblade, which is wrong. Hybrid has something like a 30% lead, back of the napkin calculation, even taking crit into account. I am just using your build for this (and it's the build I use on AD, too).

Anyway, that aside, you're ignoring the impact of hybridized damage on Reckoning. For example: a level 9 Kayle has at most rank two of Q, which is a difference of about 133 (for double Doran's AD) vs. 193-241 (for Rageblade). Literally, even without stacks on Rageblade, the difference is equal to one hit of Righteous Fury.