User blog comment:AngeMusicien/Full Tier List of AD Carries (with strange build included)/@comment-3450702-20111206200229/@comment-4128642-20111207072038

Malzahar Voidling takes 1.0 of his AD and 100% of his Armor Penetration. His W actually doesn't scale well on AP, meaning that with no AP it STILL does TONS of damage.

I wouldn't actually make a guide about something I don't know... ;) I often over-carry games with Malzahar AD and I know very well how a Voidling+W ulti combo can be devastating.

Sona steroid is awesome because it's nearly PERMANENT. While other "bonus damage" don't scale with CRIT and LIFESTEAL, you have to take into account that this one does. It's funny you actually defend Ashe and insult Sona, as they basically revolve around the same exact thing : UTILITY. Their ulti are control-oriented. They have plenty of teamplay abilities. The real difference is that Sona DPS is WAY HIGHER than Ashe's.

Saying that Sona AP has better DPS is stupid : even if that was the case (and actually that's not), it's like saying "Brand has a better DPS than Ashe". Then why don't we take brand instead of Ashe botlane ? :) You sure understand the problem in your logic. You make the very common mistake of comparing an AP with an AD or a Support : that's not the point. It's like comparing Warwick AD and AP in terms of DPS - that's just not the point.

Sona AD allows to take a second support and to "steal" Sona to the other team. This itself is sufficient to say that it's OP, as long as Sona AD is competitive. And she is : try it, you'll understand why. crazy damage, crazy utility, good range and base stats. Overall better than Ashe, and definitely a T2.

Twisted Fate is pretty much overrated - it's a good carry AD, but only on split-pushing comp. On any other scenario, all T2 and a lot of T3 are just better than him. (Typically LeBlanc is just a LOT better than TF)

As for Kayle... The only reason she's in T3 is because it would be a T2 or even T1 if the meta was to change. But in the current meta, she's a T27 - everyone knows it, and I told it again in the description.