Talk:Jarvan IV/@comment-3514681-20120121192055/@comment-4677525-20120124200920

I think a 2 or even 1 sec silence would make him OP considering he already traps them inside the crater. I mean a majority of the champs (including nearly all the mages) already have no way of escaping the crater besides flash, silencing them for 1-2 sec is just too broken.

If you think about it, Jarvan's ult is pretty damn good considering other tank's ultis (ignoring Amumu's ult). For example, people can just walk out of poor Maokai's ult, Galio's ult can be stopped with any hard cc, and Sejuani/Leona's ulti can also completely miss. Just like Jarvan, these ultis have a high potential for success, but can whiff entirely if you aren't paying attention to when champs are using their abilities. At least Jarvan's ult is guaranteed to do damage if it lands unlike the above ulti's.