User blog comment:BorosPaladin/"Must Have" for Season 3/@comment-3329234-20121217063942/@comment-5441738-20121217141559

I disagree with the points about top lane in that thread about Avarice Blade. I can't usually get all of the minions, but it's not by much. I understand their points, though.

The Black CLeaver is iffy on the ADC less because of what you're pointing out and more because of. 25% shred conditionally vs. 35% pen all the time? Not even a close call for the ADC. If you've got someone else on team in better position to take a Back Cleaver, then you probably don't need Last Whisper. It's a great item that someone should buy, but I think you're right that it's not a strong ADC item.