Talk:Atma's Impaler/@comment-4834593-20121022211138/@comment-4834593-20121025152048

I don't know how you get the idea of comparing Madreds and this.

Madreds: some armor, attack speed, damage, magic damage based on maximum health when autoattacking.

Atma's impaler: decent armor, crit chance, attack damage (so also in scalings) from own maximum health.

Only things they both have are armor (Where Madred's armor is barely enough to notice in your stats, let alone in a team fight) and damage (but Atma's gets better when you get more health, passing Madred's at 2667 hp). Plus, Madreds costs nearly twice as much gold.

You know, if you're Renekton, you don't give that much about attack speed, and just want damage. Of course, same for crit chance. Where Madred's is again worse, because that also gives magic damage you don't need, as you're casing abilities half of the time.