User blog comment:Xyclone010/Ashe Rework Idea/@comment-25235491-20140728184836

You attracted my attention with this idea on how to rework the champion I hate most.

The passive, well, if you wanted more frequent crits, you have them. I like this mechanic, actually; even though it looks like it would crit too often. 50% crit on max focus, not counting IE + Statikk Shiv. Gaining Focus out of battle is fine, but I would go for a more gung-ho approach and say that she gains the whole of her Focus as critical chance and it resets to zero when she makes a crit.

Frost Shot... I hate perma-slows, so much. This is a thing your support should have, not your Marksman. Plus, 54% slow on a crit, which with Focus will happen, is too much for my taste. You don't have to react to this, as it's for my taste.

I'm hesitant towards the changes on Volley. You added an extra Focus-oriented mechanic. The fact is, the consumption is small, and the damage from it isn't really noticeable. Volley will stay just like it used to be: only there to slow opponents down with a minor tickle, being only a bit sub-par on full Focus.

YES! Finally a meaningful boost to Hawkshot! Dealing bonus damage on a target she's revealed with it is great, because it counters bush-juking HARD, plus it suits her better as a Marksman. 90% AD, though, is extremely strong. Though, the fact that it depends on how much the enemy is slowed.

As for the legendary Ashe arrow, well... You only nerfed its early to add a passive, which is great for serial kills and teamfight cleanup, because more Focus stacks means more crits means more kills means more Focus. Though with that addition and no late-game nerf, she's looking extremely strong here.

As for your ideas, here's my opinion:

1. Passive: I'd say, change the duration to gain Focus, but not the damage. Your formula looks a bit weird to me.

2. Q: I'm not sure where I really want this to go... Slow stacking isn't really good given how slow stacks multiplicatively with all slows but the strongest reduced to one-third.

3. E: I like it as is. I'd prefer if you didn't change it.