User blog comment:NeonSpotlight/Where did comments go?/@comment-75.159.214.226-20120808093242

90 percent of the comments on each champion are bashing or inflating a champion's worth, those kinds of opinions should be on forums where people can dicuss them and use other links and logic to support opinions. reddit, solomid, clg, and so many other sites (in addition the LoL forums themselves) all do this and are moderated to ensure quality.

I don't think the comments section is ever moderated since they're so poor and almost never use citations for their opinions.

The wikia should be objective like wikipedia and any number of similar wikias that disable comments. It's bad when i get mislead by an uninformed contributor in the comments, but when everyone else gets mislead by a few stupid individuals on a wikia.

by having the comments section wiki loses its inherent purpose to have the straight facts on which people can form an educated opinion and have a foundation of understanding on champions and the game. the comments turn the site into a cesspool of bad information.

Guides often serve better content providers as well since you can see the player's ELO rating (which is the closest thing to objectively judging whether the creator has played enough to understand most aspects of the game). I also happen to think that guides that allow embeding like the ones on solomid encourage video guides as well that are extremely helpful.

TL;DR comments section is bad, leave that kind of stuff for forums and reddit.