Talk:Nocturne/@comment-61.216.175.69-20110604093612/@comment-3360527-20110610014627

Neither are OP but also they aren't very alike either. Xin's CC isnt reduced with tenacity and is more spammable. Nocts heal is better with more close targets while Xin's is single target and scales better with IAS. Noct is better at running away while Xin is better in a teamfight because of his ult.

But you are right, they're both melee champs that benefit from AD and IAS.