Talk:Jinx/@comment-24035965-20131010214642/@comment-24036287-20131010225115

While I can understand where you are coming from, but I still have to disagree on quite a few points. As you yourself say: "I know about the problematic of taking single skills of a champion and compare them to others, it just doesnt work."

About her Q -and I see people doing this a lot- you present it as if Jinx posesses both, or that the bonuses overlap. While in pow-pow, jinx may have a 130% bonus to as, but this comes at the cost of one of the shortest attack ranges in the game, as well as being mitigated by her having one of the lowest base AS in the game. You cannot simply compare the raw number with champions who have a MUCH MUCH higher base as. Fishbones on the other hand, DOES NOT gain any as bonus. You may have an aoe and range, but at the cost of mana and your single-target dps is quite low. While your team vs team dps might be high, this is highly situational and counterable and on top of this providing spread-out aoe dps is not what you want your adc to do - you want to kill prime targets, period.

About her W: yup, it does a ton of damage. It also has a delay and is telegraphed even more obviously than a thresh hook. While the poke is high, I find dodging it far easier than for example dodging Jayce E's. I'd wait nerfing this one out at least till people get the hang of dodging it, and then we'll see if the net damage is really that bad.

About her E: I guess the damage is a bit stronk, although I favor it more for its utility. I could live with a damage nerf if it would please the nerf-criers so.

About her R and Passive: R is Ezreal ult but so much slower. Can't really judge on this until I've seen it more in use and am actually able to land hits with it. Passive is pretty cool but can be countered by not watching Jinx kill your tower and instead staying away. Very stronk after first blood I suppose, but then again I'd rather have a passive helping me get FB than rewarding me for it.

After my limited Jinx play my judgment is this: we should wait at least 2 weeks so people can understand her and stop feeding her like total idiots. I've been researching Jinx days before she came out so I kinda know what I'm up against, but all the time I see people throwing themselves at her and eating W's like there's no tomorrow, ignoring all her mechanics. A number tweak on Q and E might be okay iguess, but im afraid of nerfs just because people cannot bother to dodge some lazors.

Afterall, 20 Fishbones and 2 W's cost you virtually all your mana. And then you're dead.