User blog comment:Cybersteel8/New Atma's Impaler suggestion/@comment-25200211-20140719174241

Cool idea to change it, but AS would made AA-fighters/brusiers oriented bit OP. Jax/Irelia/Shyvana with this? o_O, fighter Kayle? And bunch of others like AAtrox,Mundo, Rengar (q?),Olaf, J4, Xin, WW, Skarner, Udyr, even Vi (faster arm shred proc),Hecarim,Voli?;p,Nasus;p,Riven even or Nocturne. Not to mention the cost to utility, which would make it a bit 'situational' item. Like all my precursors said: randuin, banshee/SV and then sunfire+thornmail for all the 'tanks'. Want dmg+survi go maw or bc/hydra. With AS i would consider building fratma on Yasuo/Fiora even;p. If it would be 'tank' oriented UNIQUE MS (like 5/7/8%) is in my opinion more interesting stat. Tanks would have a better chance to peel/chase, instead of initiate and beeing kited to death by 'leage of dashes' adc. The problem with ATMA is it was nerfed together with items that made ATMA viable (Warmog, removing of Stark), combined with new, alternative more suitable items. (Maw,Hydra,BC etc). S1-2 golem meta changed to tanky brick walls to peel/initiate on top.