Talk:The Black Cleaver/@comment-46.61.90.209-20121128212731/@comment-184.32.118.131-20121207025407

I have tried the old Black Cleaver, and coming from a Renekton main, it was pretty meh. I always found LW to be more effective when I needed armor pen.

The % based armor penetration allows the AD caster to actually compete with other bruisers later on, because you know, Olaf isn't that Ezreal with less than 100 armor (unless he's stupid, of course). This whole QQing about remaking TBC is rather childish; AD carries and bruisers still have LW for armor pen and an assortment of other items for AS, while there is possible only two items in the entire game designed specifically for AD casters.

Also, I never said YGB was a good item, I just said it was designed for melee carries.