Talk:Atma's Impaler/@comment-4834593-20121022211138/@comment-5.83.71.124-20121024022149

Problem is, considering the base 40 AD and that even carries have 2K HP at lv18, Madred's bloodrazor scales better than this and gives better offensive stats, just a bit less armor. Considering that, Madred's giving you +120 damage against the squishiest enemies, while you need to get 8K HP to make this item so viable as Madred's. And I'm talking just against a squishy.

Now, only advantage compared to that is that Atma's is cheaper. But even Manamune and Archangel's staff have better synergy between the stats they give (You know, 2% AD/3% AP from your mana, but it keeps growing). Unless this item starts giving HP as you use a skill/AA, or the old 2% scaling is recovered, I don't see why people should see it so attractive as before.