User blog comment:Tankteam/ADC Tierlist/@comment-25003900-20150116170234

What exactly is the criteria for your tiers? I can't see how you came to these conclusions.

I in no way would ever consider Ezreal to be tier 1. Tier 4 Draven? What?

To put Draven so low on the list directly contradicts what you stated as "what's needed in the ADC position."

Vayne certainly doesn't deserve to be tier 2 because she'll get completely dumpstered by most ADCs in the early game, and potentialy completely shut down from getting to major late game damage without much effort. Especially against the early game super strength ADCs that are popular right now.

Lucian has been nerfed largely into oblivion and compared to most other ADCs right now, but sure he can be halfway useful in some cases or in the hands of a very skilled Lucian player.

Jinx is extremely strong right now and should probably be Tier 1. Miss Fortune and Ashe should be probably tier 3 as opposed to 4.

Twitch was my favorite ADC for a long time and it pains me to say that I think you're right with his placement.

Varus is also very much viable at this point in time.

Beyond that I'd say that you should both post stronger criteria for placement as well as not being so loose with the tier list. Every patch deserves its own list and as such you shouldn't include a rework that's not likely to hit for at least another patch possibly two.