User blog comment:AtheistUntoDeath/Which of these Champions would win? Part 3/@comment-6191229-20140516030649

Here we go:

Galio has his Q, a concussive blast. That could shatter Malphite, who is likely brittle. Galio is also an MR tank (at least usually), so Malph's magic damage won't do so much to him. However, if the battle field is surrounded by rocks, then that has the whole new factor of the battleground shattering. Galio's Q would probably break the rocks (possibly hitting Malphite), and Malph would throw the rocks around, which could act as stuns.

For mobility, Galio's wind gives him a huge edge there, and could probably blow some smaller rocks towards Malphite as well. Malph has his dash to a targeted area, but after landing he may have some recoil time.

I'm giving this to Galio, because he is more agile, has some more concussive impacts (shattering), and mainly because of why I love him mid: he gets AP and damage from MR. Put him against an AP/magic champion and get MR. He then becomes ridiculously unkillable and gets damage to boot. Plus, having a slow against an already hulking enemy kind of helps.