Talk:Nidalee/@comment-4221730-20130508053314/@comment-8506165-20130510173322

Oh Sagee... your replies are so predictable nowadays. I even headed one of your arguments off by saying that "some counterplay exists" is not the same as "balanced".

"Toxic is like everyone's go to word when they cannot fully explain why something they hate is bad for the game."

I did explain, in some detail, why I feel Nidalee's spears are bad for the game. They actively reward her for taking no risk. But you skipped right over that part. If you really want I can go into more detail, but you haven't even acknowledged the details I have provided so far.

Beyond that, you just made some assumptions about my skill based on the fact a Nidalee escaped me once with Nasus, and assume that if I have a problem with her it must be because I fed her. How about we play it in reverse? You've been caught a few times with Nidalee by a champ with the CCs you mentioned and thus you feel her escape is unreliable because of your own failings. Doesn't really advance the debate anywhere, does it?

I'm not saying the rest of her kit couldn't do with some form of buff or rework. Hell, I'd be quite happy for that to happen if it meant I wasn't at risk of taking ult-level damage from out of the range of my entire team every 4 seconds without end. 575 + 160% AP damage hurts even with a moderately farmed Nidalee, and realistically, you're not going to dodge every spear even if you have the whole damn map warded, particularly if her team have anything to say about it. So what, are all the carries expected to go MR offtank solely to counter a single champ on the enemy team? Sounds like a balance issue to me.