Talk:VPBE/@comment-4270771-20140724185127/@comment-7633726-20140726171905

The 5% max mana scaling is too much right off the bat imo. Keep in mind, Soraka's E has a 5% max mana scaling. I think if they do something like your suggestion, it shouldn't scale that high, I think it should scale to 2% max mana. It IS true damage after all. Or maybe have the scaling go up as you pay more mana starting at maybe 50 +1.5% max mana for 80 mana, 150 mana for it to go up to 3%, 220 for 4.5%, 290 for 6%, etc. up to a cap of 9% max mana? Just a thought. Idk. Based on what they've actually given us, they're wanting to make it a repeat activeated item with a stack system, so I was trying to go for that, but I probably screwed it up.

Jayce can still make use of the true damage on hit with his built in maxed AS, and if the changes go through, Corki will pick it up definitely with his low cooldown ult and his passive, he'll definitely want this both for the mana and the passive/active. I think Udyr builds will change to use this since he's pretty mana hungry anyway, and he'd get a lot out of the PBE Muramana passive/active. Irelia would probably sometimes pick it up if she was ahead, and it would get a bit out of control on those that did use it, but she'd still need to be ahead. And while Yorick, Blitz, and Urgot don't need AS, you only have to activate it once to get the added 2% max mana scaling on the true damage as it is, so there's that.

I just don't think this item is a good idea in the first place. I don't know what the goal is with it other than to improve Muramana, but I'm not sure what its purpose was meant to be with the passive/active being so..... strong I guess. I think it's a bit much.