Board Thread:Administrator's noticeboard/@comment-4652200-20121130231836/@comment-1088372-20121227021041

I do very much like talk pages on other wikis. Discussions are too global and hard to reach, and comments are mostly about the content of an article. In talk pages most talk is about the article itself, like "this paragraph should be moved to this article instead" or "I think this would fit category X more than it does category Y".

Take Spectator_Mode for example. I want to ask the question "Why is this in a FAQ style? On the one hand I'd edit the remainder of the article to continue it, but on the other hand why bother? Was it made like this to reflect an AQ session that Riot held?"

I can't ask this in the comments section because it will be pushed down by newer comments, but if I make a 'thread' in the talk page all the people following it, and could thus answer my question, are alerted by wikia emails. The answer is then inserted into the talk page by whoever.

It would fill about the same function as the discussion do now, but it's way easier to find with a link up top(If you never saw it on other wikias, it's like the "comments" tab), you instantly get all the threads relative to the article, and it's easy to implement as it's done by wikia.

Why don't we have this yet?