Talk:Alistar/@comment-5489694-20131203093942/@comment-2257477-20131204144409

You clearly don't understand why people are saying any of it then.

In a lot of cases, people are joking because he's essentially a magic moo-moo. Although past experiences have shown that people on this wiki have notoriously bad joke detection.

However, there are a couple that might be serious about it, and those people do have a good point overall, as Shinaliss pointed out- doing magic damage by sticking his horns in your ass isn't particularly coherent. It'd be like having the most stereotyped wizard ever and causing his obviously-magical abilities to do AD.

Does he NEED to be AD? Not really, Lich Bane and Manamune can do the job for direct damage, depending on the build; it's just funny to make fun of him for being a magical cow when he makes Arnold Schwartzanegger look like a pretty skinny guy.