User blog comment:ImbaBrony/Ashe rework/@comment-4881935-20121102160607/@comment-4881935-20121102181158

^ No u did not.

For the passive, u remove the requirement of not attacking and just allowed it to stack endlessly.

For Q, u just added extra magic damage and scaling. Mana cost slightly change.

For W, it's the exact same.

For E, bonus gold added.

For R, bonus AD scaling.

Not a remake. A remake implies either some form of change in style, build, or distinct change in abilities. None of your changes does any of that. All of them are just straight up buffs to make her better at killing.

Also, Ashe isn't that weak where she needs all those buffs. Even that passive change alone (with nothing else changing) might be too much.