Talk:Executioner's Calling/@comment-217.136.33.32-20130121220734/@comment-190.19.250.58-20130201003012

crit chance is strong when coupled with AS and more crit chance. Riven for example doesnt do good with this item. Irelia maybe, but she still usually build tanky + triforce or gauntlet so she wont have a lot of AD to couple the crit chance. Shyvana usually goes AS with not a lot of AD so she wont make a good use of  crit chance.

Top laners are usually bruisers, they can go AD or AS but they wont go both. Champions that get both AD and AS are melee AD carries (tryn GP Master yi and fiora)

those champions want to deal a lot of damage with auto attacks, in that case, yes, they can do it with crit chance, but in the case of most top laners, they either go AD or AS, not both, and without both stats, crit chance is almost useless as it either to hard to proc or the proc is to weak.