User blog comment:Reinbow/Some Custom Champions need more attention./@comment-1330314-20130524124106

There are a few reasons custom champions don't get commented on much: Firstly, most people involved in custom champions are mainly output-focused, i.e. they're only here to post their champion ideas and receive feedback. Everybody has an idea for a champion they want to share, but nobody's really seeking out new champion concepts to review. Secondly, the sheer number of custom champion ideas, combined with the huge variability in quality among them, means people who do check new champion concepts tend to skim them and reserve any comments they may have to themselves.

Not wanting to be a jerk or act pretentious, but this is mainly the fault of champion creators. As Nhan said, we need to give feedback to other champs if we want the same to happen to our concepts, and we also need to aim for quality rather than quantity, giving more thought to our concepts and refining them over time rather than bouncing from one new idea to another. People who look at our champions will be more inclined to give feedback if they know we care sufficiently about our concept to change it and try to make it the best we can.

The other main problem here is that every contributor here is an island, in the sense that despite there being an actual custom champ community on the wiki we're all disconnected from each other and are limited to our own blogs. I'm all up for creating a section entirely dedicated to new champion concepts, which'd update like the activity feed and allow us to rate and comment on them. That way, we could also have a portion for the most popular/best-rated concepts, which'd be a good incentive to produce good-quality champions.