Board Thread:Wiki discussions and announcements/@comment-3308937-20140828121932/@comment-24023648-20140906101043

Willb32764 wrote:

Pros: Contains information about basic ways to play the champion, very useful to new players. Contains the Recommended Builds as determined by Riot, this must be kept. Contains Official Strategy for newer champions as suggested by Riot. Contains information on how to effectively counter the champion, very useful when facing champions you have never faced. Allows user to easily contribute the wiki.

Recommended Builds, Champion's Spotlights & Official Strategy & Synergy/Countering are Riot's point of view and should not be blended with random wiki users tips. The problem in remaking the Strategy page to contain those and only those would be of course the lack of Official Strategy & Synergy/Countering for most of the champions.

Willb32764 wrote:

Cons: Contains outdated information that may mislead readers.

Interesting here is that some builds recommended by Riot and champions' spotlights are outdated themselves. How do you even decide what's misleading and what not? That's very subjective.

Willb32764 wrote:

Cons: Contains information that is posted by people who are inexperienced.

Wrong, it contains subjective information not uttered by Riot. I see that you also like to judge those people recommending hextech on Nami when the problem is elsewhere.

I think patch history should not be included in a Dev/BtS page but I don't think it would be better on the main page. But again, a 'History' page that would include it and all the outdated information is also tricky.

And my feedback about skins: I don't want to see them everytime I'm scrolling down the main page to the comments. I don't think Skins are the priority for someone who searches a champion.

The way to redesign the champion's mainspace proposed by Neon and Empty may be flawed like Teh pointed out. But I don't agree with him that things should remain the same, as I consider the current Strategy & Background pages pretty messed up.