User blog comment:AtheistUntoDeath/Which of these Champions would win? Part 3/@comment-8091380-20140517183224

first of all, i don't speak english, so this won't be easy to explain, but lets see what I can do xD

I think that some information and theorys about malphite are necesary to make a good argument about his pottential fighting abilities outside the League of Legends.

Malphite comes from a world where everybody and everything are part frome a whole, it's sound almost like "Neon Genesis Evangelion" vision of a perfect world where everybody is one and all at the same time. So we can assume that Malphite didn't actually have a standar physical form in that world, probably changing according to his duty at the moment (still since to be primarely be made of rock-like materials).

When summoned to Runterra, they just grabbed Malphite conscius and part of the rocks from that world, and Malphite then used that material to form a "emergency" physical form. why I am saying all this things? because if anything of this is taking as a fact, we can asume that Malhpite form in the league is just a limited one that the summoners limited to him. In his new artwork he can be seen as huge as a mountain, his others skins show that he can use any solid material to form a body and his passive in game seems to generate another layer from material arround him aslong as he can concentrate with out taking dmg. So in theory Malphite would be able to grow as much as his mind/spirit/power can handle using any environment to his favor, so far the limit seems to be the one showed in his classic artwork.

About Galio, there isn't much about his lore that give us any information about his figthing abillities or powers outside the league, so most of the theorys must be done with the in game information. he is a Mage/tank with limited flying abillities... and thats about it. He seems to be powerfull since it was the master creation of Duran the Artificer, but he didn't have the power to stop a bunch of noxian assassins (altought the lore never said the number, in theory they could had been 1000) to kill his master, his whole reason to exist. So his power shouldn't be thaaat great.

the fight

since the field is wide open and they have clear view each other from the beggining, it would be hard on Malphite to increase his size since he needs to concentrate to do so, Galio can just use his magic from the distance to avoid that risk.

On the other side, Galio fliying seems to be a little basic, so it wouldn't be so easy from him to dodge all malphite rock throwing attacks, but since he is a natural tank (made from rock and metal) it wouldn't do much dmg.

So they both well be doing little dmg from the distance over and over, again and again with out much effect, since malphite can regenerate and galio is a gargoyle that was years looking to his dead master body with out ever need to restore his energy, so we can asume that he won't get tired soon in that fight.

At close combat Malhpite seems to have te advantage having much more physical power, and eventually a single distraction from galio or a smart move using the envioroment to his favor will cost galio the victory

winner

Malphite would win.

Galio is resistent and has some advantage at distance, but any dmg done to him will acumulate and eventually reduce his movement (wich isn't that great). and if malphite ever get's close to him, that would be mostly hiis end.

wow, that wasn't easy to explain, i will be waiting for the results xD