Thread:Grrrbear26/@comment-26044269-20150516055631

Primary Rules

 * A concept must have a link to the main CB page to be eligible for judging.
 * A concept must abide by the main challenge of the CB it is partaking in to be eligible for judging.
 * A concept must be (plagiarism shouldn't be allowed anyway) to be eligible for judging.
 * A concept must have been submitted by the submission deadline to be eligible for judging.
 * A concept may still partake in a CB without being eligible for judging, if it has been submitted before the submission deadline. Nevertheless, as it is not eligible for judging, it cannot be judged and therefore can only acquire points from the public evaluation poll. Reasons as to why a concept is not eligible for judging must be listed at the top of its page.

Secondary Rules

 * Concepts which are not eligible for judging may be disqualified from a CB at the judges' discretion.
 * Contestants may only have up to 1 concept in which is eligible for judging. If a contestant has more than 1 concept which could be considered eligible for judging, they will have to mark one of their concepts as ineligible for judging before the submission deadline, lest the judges mark one of them as ineligible for judging at random.
 * Contestants are discouraged from editing their concepts after the submission deadline.

Scoring

 * All concepts start with 0 points.
 * Concepts which are eligible for judging are given 1 point. (Max points possible at this point: 1)
 * After the submission deadline has been reached, judges evaluate the entered concepts at random.
 * Concepts which abide to the challenge of the CB are given up to 2 points, at the judges' discretion. (Max points possible at this point: 3)
 * Concepts which display very strongly the characteristics of negative applications of anti-patterns are deducted up to 2 points, at the judges' discretion. (Max points possible at this point: 3)
 * Concepts are then given up to 2 points points based on how cohesive and creative their kits are, at the judges' discretion. Judges should try to come to an agreement as to how many points a concept will be given. In the chance they do not, the average of the points given by the judges are given to the concept. (Max points possible at this point: 5)
 * After the judges have evaluated all the entries, a public evaluation poll with the following categories are posted: most original/creative concept and personal favorite. Concepts which are voted 1st and 2nd in the most original/creative concept are given 2 points and 1 point respectively, whilst the concepts voted 1st, 2nd and 3rd in the personal favorite are given 3 points, 2 points and 1 point respectively. Voters are not encouraged to post reviews/reasons as to their vote in order to respect anonymity and privacy, but are welcomed to. (Max points possible at this point: 10)

Winning

 * The concept with the most points win (duh) and the contestant who entered the winning concept is deemed a judge for the next two CBs. Concepts which place 2nd and 3rd should also be recognized.
 * In the event of a tie, the judges are to discuss the winner of the CB via chat or pm. 