Talk:Lucian/Background/@comment-4596819-20130729182935/@comment-4247199-20130731174808

The grammatical one was just me poking fun, for the record. No hard feelings.

I don't mean that it was fan speculation at all, but merely it's specified as speculation in Evelynn's lore. The fact of the matter is that nobody knows, and that the alters don't interact with her doesn't really help her case in terms of being from the Shadow Isles.

I also just kind of assumed that champions were joining the League chronologically as they're released by Riot. So while I suppose that doesn't make it impossible that Eve could have been related to the two, and it just took them a while to join the League, it just seems odd that she would have joined before they would.

There's still the issue that neither Lucian nor Thresh seem to recognise Evelynn at all. Though I suppose if she were to be reincarnated then she could have a different appearance. You'd think she might say something to Lucian, though.

Thresh keeps the souls he captures in his lantern, forever. So while, I don't know, I guess it's possible for her to have directly contradicted Thresh's sole purpose of existence and broken out or something, it certainly doesn't make perfect sense.