Talk:Sivir/@comment-186.136.187.224-20130105151008

IMO they need to buff her, her W E and R are all weak. Her old ricochet was way superior, the new one doesnt only cost more mana it doesnt deal that much damage. Annie's shield cost only 20 mana, that should be ricochets mana cost. Ezreal has a lower mana cost on his Q and it also applies on hit effects, stack his passive and has a massive range with a 1:1 AD ratio and huge base damage.

Her E is maybe the only cool part of her kit, but because you shouldnt max it first it has a huge cooldown and doesnt refund enough mana to make it worth it.

And her ult is cool on teamfights, but outside that situation it doesnt provide neither the mobility nor the 1vs1 potencial it should. 20% MS? For 10 seconds? It only helps chasing champions through the entire map, but it doesnt bring the mobility you get when you play ezreal graves or even caitlyn. It is maybe the only ultimate that just feels awful in all situations except for teamfights. Caitlyn Ezreal Ashe Corki Graves Kog Maw Twitch MF Varus they all get an ultimate that has a huge impact and makes you feel good for using it, Sivir ultimate doesnt feel that powerful and unless you have an AD top and jungler, it wont be that powerful, it only gives her 60% AS at max rank... thats 10% more AS than ezreal's passive. She only gets 30% AS at level 6 and the effect is HALVED on allies... wtf. 15% bonus AS for allies? Ezreals W gives you 20% deals damage charge your passive and it onlys rank 1... at rank 5 it gives you 40% thats higher than sivirs ult.

The thing that bothers me the most is that if you lane with a random support on solo Q, you will get harrass the entire lane phase, for example, caitlyn vs sivir, sivir eats her traps to get mana back yes... but then caitlyn smacks you with auto attacks and dodge your Q with ease. Same goes for most lanes, her range is poor and her abilities doesnt make up for that, she really need some love, not only a visual rework.