Board Thread:Wiki discussions and announcements/@comment-3308937-20140828121932/@comment-3308937-20140903134850

Vsagent wrote: snip

Well, that could have been phrased better :x In regards to comments vs a page, I really don't see the problem with comments. It has the same formula of a strategy page (different people coming together with different experiences and playstyles) except you can actually see where and who each idea comes from (so you can see that the guy who told you about this amazing combo you can do on Fizz isn't also telling you to build infinity edge on him) so that it's easier to see that that's exactly what it is, different people with different experiences and the ability for other people to give their individual thoughts and expand on other people's ideas without directly modifying them. Not to mention you get to pick and choose which ones you feel are appropriate instead of just having a long page that reads a lot like a guide.

Moving existing strategy page content to talk pages like an archive is fine by me because there is no set purpose for talk pages since comments took over their original purpose and if people feel they want to edit them as time goes by then I won't stop them but at the same time I wouldn't go out of my way to patrol them for trolls or vandalism and I don't really expect any other mod to do so either.