Talk:Swain/@comment-31543294-20180216070159/@comment-3391671-20180218002135

I kind of have to agree with TAG, although not with the "suck" part. The comparison are rather loose and overly critical in weird places.

Q is nothing like 's, neither in size, target peramater, damage or more. If anything, I would call it an ability version of 's.

W works a differently from ', as cannot be used in a barrage, neither is its purpose the same. If anything, you may have referred to the wrong ability as Xerath's is ground-targeted and applies a slow after a delay. So, W is more like plus.

Not every ability has to be new. Can you make a new ability out of ? Old E was just a different version of 's. Comparing it to 's ; comparing only the boomerange aspect is shallow, my friend, as there are other boomerang abilities closer to this new E, such as 's. Just consider... is there any abilities that boomerang, but cannot pass-through on its way back? No, right?

I didn't know could heal herself during her. Isn't this new R... just an improvement of old R? As mentioned above, does everything need to be new? No, not really. If the team can modernize the kit, old effects that are still viable can remain. Thus, the ability to heal in an area about himself while still being able to move had been kept (thus are not at all alike to Kat). The purpose of this ability is not to deal the same amount of damage as Kat anyways, so why the comparison.

If you were serious with this comparison Schooking, then I will have to say that your analysis are just too shallow to be taken seriously taken. If you were joking... then it seems like the joke had gone over TAG's and my heads. Maybe you should have made it more obvious.