Talk:Madred's Bloodrazor/@comment-8520635-20130518051843/@comment-5266525-20130602162158

Except it wasn't really good. Champions who like the AD on this item can barely make any use out of the passive on tanky targets (ie. the people who you'd build this to counter in the first place) because they don't build MPen. Onhit champs who like the passive on this can barely make any use out of the AD because they don't build ArmPen. Both types of champions may or may not have even appreciated the armor, which by itself was an extremely small amount for a lategame Season 2 item where armor was greatly reduced in price. It's a mishmash of stats put onto a heavily overpriced item with a passive that is only actually useful to a very narrow selection of champions.

Honestly, if they went with your suggestion we'd just end up with a poor-man's BotRK anyway, so I don't know what you're complaining about.