Talk:Kayle/@comment-175.139.24.188-20120623090822/@comment-2124153-20120626164902

AD Kayle top basically forces the enemy to itemize Armor, because there are two AD carries. It's not sufficient to just jump on a carry and take them out with CC. This makes it easier on your mage, moreso if you have a magic-based jungler like Shyvana or Amumu.

On-hit Kayle is mostly magic damage, which can put more pressure on your bursters in certain circumstances since the enemy will build MR (although not Kayle, since she brings her own shred). She's better at pushing towers than mages (most mages do not build Lich Bane, and some of the ones that do can't consistently activate the proc), but not as good as AD Kayle. The crit is not very relevant here, AS/AD is stronger than AS/nothing.