Talk:Alistar/@comment-5489694-20131203093942/@comment-4022742-20131217131609

So the argument here is that it being a physical action has nothing to do with magic!? Then what about other supports like, and ?

It's arbitrary but is basically bashing people in the face, shouldn't it be physical damage then? No? Because his hammer gets imbued with magical power from his spells....

Now I get it magically transports her and stuff, but what about ? Physically bash someone over the head with a shield! Magic damage? Doesn't this also make no sense then?

The biggest sinner of all might be ! is fine, souls empowering his basic attacks, sure why not magical! and make no sense whatsoever, throw a hook in someone's face MAGIC DAMAGE, throw around your chain to damage people, of course very magical!

If we take a look at a lot of other champions too, there's more that doesn't make sense: There's probably even more, like and his turrets. The thing is a lot of these don't make sense, but have to happen for build and functional coherence. If Alistar his kit needs to be changed to AD and HP ratio's just because their animations imply them. Then good luck reworking about 60% of the entire champion pool ;)
 * throw a Kama in someone's face, deal magic damage.
 * and punch someone's face, deal magic damage.
 * throw a cleaver in someone's face, deal magic damage.
 * shoot a bolt of energy in someone's face, deal physical damage.
 * shoot cannonballs in someone's face, deal magic damage.
 * slam your body in someone's face, deal magic damage.
 * shoot a ball of energy in someone's face, deal physical damage.
 * shoot a wave of sound in someone's face, deal physical damage. (Don't give me that kung fuu crap, I know magic when I see it!)
 * I'ma firin' mah Lazor in someone's face, deal physical damage.
 * throw an anchor in someone's face, deal magic damage.
 * , AND  Throw a spear or claw at people's faces, deal magic damage.
 * throw a blade made of shadow in someone's face, deal physical damage.
 * bash someone's face against a wall, deal magic damage.
 * throw a dagger in someone's face, deal magic damage.
 * throw a blade in someone's face, deal magic damage.
 * fling someone's face over your head, deal magic damage.
 * thrust a stinger in someone's face, deal magic damage.
 * and, jump on someone or shoot a cannonball in someone's face, deal magic damage.
 * throw gamecards into someone's face, deal magic damage.
 * and claw off someone's face, deal magic damage.