User blog comment:Witchking99/Judgement, The Assassin of Justice V.2/@comment-10540150-20140115073459/@comment-10540150-20140115082601

Okay, took a second look at the numbers and realized his very low range combined with low resistances makes for a very squishy target. Like, really squishy. Nonetheless, his Q still allows him to build tanky while still assassinating high priority carries. So, let's do some theorycrafting, which I'm doing AS I write.

Base MR at level 18 is 52.5. Base Armor at the same level is a flat 80. Base AD at 18 is 105.8, which I'm assuming is rounded up to 106. It's entirely possible I'm doing the statistics wrong, so if someone wants to correct me, go ahead.

Full Build that I'm going to use, just picking basic tank items out of the lot, is:

Choice of Boots, either Merc's or Tabi, probably. Rushing Tabi would be good to make up for his low armor, whereas Merc's lets him nab that carry more easily. Banshee's Veil, Maw of Malmortius, Guardian Angel, either Thornmail or Mercurial Scimitar, and finally an Atma's just for shiggles.

Not gonna factor in boots, but this full build gives me, with Thornmail: 187.5 MR, 275 Armor, and 202 AD factoring in the bonus AD from Atma's. Not the three hundred I was expecting, but even so, nothing is stopping me from instagibbing their ADC if he even thinks of getting fed. As I've demonstrated repeatedly, 202 X 10 kills is 2020, plus the true damage from your ult. For reference, this tank build, while it is capitalizing on resistances, does give me less than 2500 health, if I recall correctly. And this doesn't even factor in crits or Spellblade passives. If it did, then I'd swap out Thornmail for Trinity Force and the amazing 200% AD Instanuke.

And of course, if taking him top lane, Thornmail is only 2200g. Pretty quick buy if you want to get tanky fast.

The thing about this guy is, he has no potential outside of instagibbing. None. He will do nothing if no one gets fed. Which is still okay because then no one gets fed.