Talk:Sivir/@comment-26509580-20150822183235/@comment-26227836-20150825070917

I wanna say Sivir but Ashe may have the advantage depending on how much critical chance/damage they have.

Furthermore, Ashe has the range advantage so Sivir may be auto'd once before landing her own. The only way she can overcome that advantage is with her W auto attack reset.

Then it comes down to Sivir and Ashe's Q and W, respectively. Sivir's Q hits harder but it's somewhat dodgable and decreases in damage depending on units hit, unlike Ashe's W.

Also, Ashe has 2 damaging abilities. Ashe's ult is sidesteppable while her W isn't. If Sivir elects to Spell Shield Ashe's ult, she will probably take a lot of damage (assuming Ashe's W doesn't get blocked by minions).

But this is really looking at a 1v1 scenario. In lane, Sivir probably wins this one.