Talk:Kayle/@comment-88.102.160.74-20120501150030/@comment-24.102.156.60-20120502162523

I re- ran the calculations and as I thought the situations are not nearly as clear cut though yes vayne does do significantly more damage so I retract my previous statement. The target: a 3000 hp target with no armor or mr. 4 seconds worth of AA's. The build is zerks, IE, PD, and BT. I will not be employing kayles passive for the sake of ease of calculations.

Damage over 4 seconds no abilities (kayle gets her E, vayne's silver bolts procs twice):

Kayle: 3675.9

Vayne: 3969.6

Damage over 4 seconds with abilities (for kayle this means her Q, for vayne everything including her ult):

Kayle: 4043.5

Vayne: 5310

So yes, vayne does significantly more damage ranging from 10% more to 30% more. I didn't count kayle's passive like i said as that would make it too difficult. Some things to consider: The utility of kayle's heal and the damage mitigation of her ultimate. Kayle seems like ashe in that her damage might not be as high as other carries but her utility has huge potential to more than make up for it.