Talk:Yasuo/@comment-3460935-20160927030802/@comment-24802981-20161001101623

Why not give Yas % Crit based off Bonus AD u say? N also % AD based on Crit from other source?

Step by step, Crit increases overall damage done by critable sources by 1% per 1% crit chance (or 1.5/1 with IE). If Yas has % Crit based off Bonus AD, that is gaining %Attack Damage by building Attack Damage, which is bullshit.

%AD based on Crit? Jhin n Fiora may have powerful Basic Attack, but unlike Yas, they are Casters.

Jhin wants crit like any normal ADC, but to encourage him to build more crit instead of just straight AD heavy items, he has that %Crit to %Bonus AD. (U see Varus? He s also an ADC that rely heavily on Spell to deals damage. Normally people need CDR on him more than Crit, and a Varus without Crit can do just fine).

Fiora don't build crit much. She doesn't. She has nothing like Yas' Crit Bonus. If you try to compare Yas with Fiora just because she has that E with guarranteed Crit, then I guess Shaco will be the same. Fiora needs CDR.

In the game now, there r only 2 items that gives both Crit n AD, IE n Soul Reaver. If u have both, u have 40% crit chance. That means if u want Crit, u have to also get items like Static Shiv or Phantom Dancer, which give 30% Crit + lots of Attack Speed. Unlike Jhin n Fiora, Attack Speed is something Yas really needs - in return, CDR is almost useless on Yas. So, if a Yas builds Shiv or Dancer, Yas gets Crit +AS, but not high as fuk AD. If Yas gains %AD based on Bonus Crit, then well he can sits on just the Shiv, IE, Phantom dancer n have around 500 AD, n also around 2.0 AS + 100% Crit chance.

The current passive works fine. While it gives him bonus on Crit, it also limits how useful Crit is on Yas, 2 crit items and it maxes out 100%. Yas is intended to be a fighter, so he s not supposed to be full glass cannon. He s melee, who s fights in the middle of danger. So 2 Crit items s enough + some Tank items + Life Steal if needed.

Current Yas tank is good because its Tank meta now. Not just Yas s building tank, Yi, Ekko, Ire, ... r also doing it.