Talk:Ashe/@comment-24299177-20150507092306/@comment-11013454-20150509185922

You need to propose a scaling then. And then you need to ask the question "is this actually neccesary, or is this just something i want her to have because i think it would be cool."

Does it get a scaling on frosted targets? Because again, frost is a 2 second debuff that will almost never apply to targets your hitting from far away and goes against the design of the skill being a global stun snipe.

Does it get a scaling on distance? Because it already does that

Does it get a AD scaling? How much?

Does it get some kind of late game scaling? Why?

Cause currently it scales with level, which is natural progression, and distance which essentially is a reward for good aim.

Her passive crit modifier is something that applies on auto attacks, physical damage. It doesn't increase the damage of her projectile skills and her ult arrow is magical and magic based. A shoehorning of this passive into her ult doesn't make sense.

Don't get me wrong buddy, i'm not trying to shoot you down, but you need to draw a line when you're reworking champions to keep them balanced, or atleast as close to balanced as you can. Everything you change needs to have a purpose as well as not cause her to overperform. It also needs to be as straightforward as possible because the more variables you add the more things you need to balance which sets other thigns off balance. She might be picked more than she should, Riot will notice this and then nerf her in some other way that will be undesirable.

This is why i brought on the 'don't fix what isn't broken' comment. You have to pretend Ashe is a building that needs repair and you only have a certain budget. If you go over the budget adding unnecesary things 'for the sake of having the thing and it would look nice ' then you go into debt or you don't fix what was acutallyt he problem. Ashe's Q and passive were sub par and were the main reasons she underperformed as an ADC. Her W, E and R were resonable skills that gave her enough benefit out of using them (An AOE, vision and hard CC)