Talk:Sheen/@comment-75.85.45.121-20121211163902

Layout 1 doesn't have all the information that the others do.

Original has the feel of a footnote or a picture on the side. At least it has all the information there, all the item costs, sell value, and upgrade costs. It has the menu location part, which is good for completely new people, unnecssary for others. And the point of list the item code is unncessary for many, but it should be kept there.

Layout 2 is a compact version of the original. It is a bit odd to have the costs and values above the passive. It separates the stats from the passive, which should be together. Otherwise, it is a visual improvement. Still, the costs and recipe should be together.

Layout 1 feels disorganized when it isn't. The recipe and costs should be together and the cost of the items should be with the recipe. Item effects should be in a column rather than 2 columns. You could go Stats on the left, and have the special passives or actives in the middle, but then what do you do when there are multiple actives? It would be better to have stats on top, followed by other effects. Stats are a quick read, effects are not.

Thus my vote: Layout 2. It is cleaner although the separation of recipe and cost makes it a visual change.

Layout 1 is complete reorganization but lacks spacing to keep similar things together.