Talk:Rumble/@comment-4140664-20120724214459/@comment-71.142.70.239-20120725014121

I think you might have misunderstood me; I'm fine with Rumble as he is right now. But BECAUSE they want to nerf his Q (as their are more ticks that are applying now), why not just nerf the base damage by say... 20-40 at rank 5 [585-540] instead of "fixing" his Q again. I'd rather have it hit more Q ticks hit consistently at the cost of a bit lower base damage than have Q ticks not hit consistently, but still have a higher base damage.

You're right about Garen, he's extremely OP. Must be removed from the game. But what Garen lacks is first of all, his ult executes, which can steal kills from the carries, etc. While he has a 2.5 second silence, he must reach the person as well. Any smart player will avoid being silenced, and if he silences the usual tanky jungler/top laner, it won't do much effect. (Say Nocturne for example). Moreover, while he gets "tankier" it doesn't help his damage output. Moreover, his "spin to win" can be avoided through kiting, or just building armor straight out. Rumble, however, has a Q on a practically 3 second cool down, if you didn't silence yourself yet. Has a great slow through ultimate and rylais, which means he can stick AND get to the carry easily. His AoE damage is amazing, and his ms buff can get him to 500 ms if running ms quints + acquiring a shield. His stacking slow is also no laughing matter. I'd rather have a Rumble on my team than a Garen any day. :P

But anyways, I think the Rumble nerf will be interesting, but most likely more than disappointing.