Board Thread:Wiki discussions and announcements/@comment-3308937-20140828121932/@comment-658634-20140906021850

As a feedback for versions: LonelyFlame wrote: Please explain what you mean by 'one article per skin'. Do you mean it's own page? Or it own tab? In a wiki an article is something with a unique URL. Even redirect page is considered an article, just with a special purpose and quite short one. Rule of thumb: if you can categorize it, its an article. I was about to use the roles (e.g. Marksman) as an example but I noticed they are all quite horrible articles and in a horrible mess in structure sense. I shall take look at them.
 * Basic champion info
 * Missing the 1st and 18th level stats. Those zero level stats are cute, but serve no purpose for any reader as no one is playing level zero champion and they want to know what kind of figures they are looking when game starts and when they road ends. Making reader to calculate them or to check them from separate article is just bullshitting.
 * Structure
 * There should not be any notes. All that has been written in the notes are directly related to specific ability thus they should be included to them.
 * Pets are placed after abilities, yet they are part of some ability thus they should be included directly after/with them. Also 'pet' is a terrible header as they all have a name. e.g. Sand soldier, Voidling and so on. Rather use them as a header.
 * No ToC makes mobile reading hard and navigation hard. Specially when the articles tend to be quite long at the present format.
 * Abilities should be their own articles that are pulled to the champions page. A bigger project but also only way to get any dynamic lists and the abilities in categories. Also it allows history/patch notes to be included to the relative place instead of filling champion page.
 * Background actually includes only Lore thus Lore would be more fitting name. If it includes _background_ of the hero it would also include the development part.
 * Trivia should not have its own section as most of the stuff in those sections are either related to the history/development/background to he champion or to its skinn(s) and the trivia should be noted there. e.g. If azir says something funny and its worth noting, included to the section/place that handles azir talking. That way the reader has the relevant info at relevant place.
 * Recommended items is simply restating what game itself says, in a really clumsy, fixed width. If the info is only a copy&paste, then it gives very very little to the reader.
 * Skins
 * By having each skin at their own article you dodge lot of your problems you are trying to tackle now. By having e.g. a Final Boss Veigar it would include all the trivia, media and anything related to the skin. Then part of those (name, price, picture) can be pulled to the champion article in to a slide show where from the reader can head to more specific info from that skin to the skins own page. At the present way you are trying to cram too much stuff into one article making all the champion pages heavy. Plus it makes impossible to have them in categories.
 * Layout
 * Some parts use the whole width of the page (as per the new wikia layout plan) and some do not. Looks non-consistent and lengthens the article for no good reason.