Talk:V1.0.0.153/@comment-68.36.134.215-20121217124815/@comment-65.129.150.88-20130101123008

@  50.53.139.17

What Shaw said was legitimate. Shaw was disproving a point, and thus it was valid to pick out certain examples where the previous claim did not hold (disproof by counter-example).

The previous poster was basically trying to prove by examples, where the examples were not near universal. This is not logically sound. therefore cherry picking is actually an issue.