Talk:The Black Cleaver/@comment-50.136.55.199-20121213162925

Honestly, there's two routes to make this item balanced. Either make the armor penetration unique, or remove the health portion of it, making it build out of something else... not sure what, but the fact that you can stack them and gain survivability and huge damage isn't healthy.

If it were up to me, I'd just remove the health portion. AD casters stacking them is a fine tactic, and one that I don't think should be removed, but make that same AD caster squisher because of it. Don't give them everything in one package.